The District Press

Your local, independent soccer media outlet!

District Soccer News

‘Glue’ and ‘Inspiration’: The ongoing renaissance of Andi Sullivan

If it’s quintessential to the American women’s soccer experience—good, horrendous, and everything in between—Andi Sullivan has experienced it.

She tore her ACL in college, then came back to win a National Championship and the MAC Hermann trophy in college. She was drafted #1 overall (to the Washington Spirit). In her first three years as a pro she finished near the bottom of the league (2018), and won a championship (2021). She’s been through a coach abuse scandal, a good ol’ boys network that made her and her teammates unsafe. She became a leader and spokesperson and endured a prolonged and public battle to secure ownership that would give players what they deserve. She helped craft and spread one of the most badass letters from players to ownership ever made public. She was one of the few white woman soccer players to show solidarity with Black teammates and fans by kneeling for the anthem in the aftermath of Breonna Taylor and George Floyd’s murders. She’s played for the USWNT. She’s been heavily criticized and turned into a scapegoat for poor coaching decisions in international competition. She tore her ACL a second time. She became a mother. She returned to the pitch. She’s rediscovered her form. And now, she’s here, as a newer version of herself.

All this is why it’s an impossible to task to sum up this moment for Andi Sullivan. In some ways it’s just another mile marker along a career that’s been filled with ups, downs and the gamut of multidirectional experiences in between. There’s been too much investment for this moment to ever be just that. It took countless deposits in the form of triumph, pain, sadness, fear, unknowns, frustration, recovery, rebirth, birth, plus the run of the mill blood, sweat and tears that every athlete talks about, to get here. Knowing where Sullivan has been makes her arrival to this moment a rich and developed comeback story, but that risks rolling the credits too soon, and missing the really good part.

Sullivan described herself at her core as a people-pleaser. She’s a calm leader who leads through example and compassion. If something needs to be done, she would do it. Through some of the darkest days at the Washington Spirit, Sullivan took on the role as spokesperson of the club and team. Jason Anderson, of Green Line Soccer, recently asked Sullivan about how her role as a leader and captain has evolved, and Sullivan admitted that she was probably named captain too early. Not because she made glaring errors or let it go to her head (lol, imagine), but because it was a behemoth of a burden early in her professional career. She speaks about that time not with regret—it was necessary, and former and current teammates needed her in those moments—but with clarity and honesty about its emotional and exhaustive impact. In a normal ecosystem, players wouldn’t have to band together to dislodge an abusive coach, an employee who made them unsafe, and ownership whose instincts were to protect employees over players.

In addition, Andi Sullivan was also called on to be a fixture in the new era of the USWNT, particularly its midfield. Sam Mewis was forced to retire early through injury, Julie Ertz called it quits, and suddenly there was a need to plug-in another quality defensive-focused midfielder, and few had more qualifications to take on the role than Sullivan. With it came expectations. Obviously of excellence and a goal-filled party every time the USWNT take the pitch, but also to replicate styles of play that were familiar to the team. A gargantuan task that grew Godzilla-sized thanks to radioactive tactical decision by then-national team head coach Vlatko Andonovski. His preferred style of play is more defensive than the USWNT could ever be allowed to be, certainly not after winning the 2019 World Cup, the team’s fourth and one that reshaped elite women’s soccer in America. The result was a disconnected midfield as two of Sullivan’s supposed midfield partners joined attack after attack, leaving oceans of space for Sullivan to cover. When this (predictably) did not work, the flood of comments and criticism came.

For Sullivan, the people-pleaser, it was a difficult time. She noted before her season ending ACL injury in 2024 that she scaled back from social media. The internal conflict Sullivan was grappling with was that she of course wanted to excel on the team and in her role, but wasn’t, while also being told by her coaches that she was doing what was asked of her. That tension led to frustration and an attempt to solve the problem by trying to be what everyone needed her to be. This, also predictably, did not work.

As Sullivan ticked off the incremental steps to return from the double-shot of rehabbing an ACL injury and recovering from pregnancy—ending maternity leave to return to the active roster, making her first substitute appearance, her first start, first interceptions, tackles and completed passes, as well as her first lost duels, misplaced passes and recovery runs, her first full 90, her first back-to-back starts, and so on—there was also the matter of rediscovering what her body could do, and what she wanted it to do. The process was a rebirth, of sorts, of Andi Sullivan the soccer player.

It’s not often that anyone gets to undergo a self-renaissance at just 30 years old. Whatever that number is, it’s a mere fraction for professional athletes. Primarily thanks to the simple barrier of time. Athlete careers are short, and shortened further by injury. It’s typically impossible to find the time required to undergo the factory reset required to make substantive changes to yourself and the ways in which you perform. The only time away from the constant cycle of training, playing, recovering and training again is when a player faces a lengthy injury recovery. Even then, each step is pointed at returning to the pitch as soon as physically able. This, along with the primary blessing of her daughter Millie, was the gift of pregnancy.

There is no possible way to fully capture the multiple sensations and emotional whirlpool that comes from rehabbing an ACL and navigating pregnancy at the same time. Players use terms like “glue,” “motivational,” and “amazing” to describe what Sullivan has gone through and what she means to the team, and her coach calls her an “inspiration.” But looking back, Sullivan credits the process with allowing her to learn multiple lessons that would help her grow as a person, and while at times she felt a millennia away from being back on the pitch and performing, she knew that if she were to get there, a new version of herself awaited there too.

When asked about that process, Sullivan points to patience as the greatest lesson through it all. Within that patience is also acceptance—of where she and her body are and what it needs, and the unknowable timeline of when it will get there (sometimes even how). Ask your local perfectionist how they’d handle all that uncertainty. It didn’t matter; there was one path, it was her own, it’d never been travelled, and she had no idea how long it was. The only thing left to accept, every day, in the hard days, blah days and good days, was that whatever label the day earned was just a day along the path, and that at the end of it she would be one day closer.

Among of the sharpest lessons of Sullivan’s renaissance has been that there are very few opinions about her play that she needs to listen to, and that her own is valuable. Ahead of the Spirit’s first playoff game this postseason, Sullivan spoke about having to implement some Hal Hershfelt—her midfield partner who tore her ACL against Kansas City, two games before the playoffs—into her game. Head coach Adrián González disagreed, reaffirming that the only player Andi Sullivan needs to be is “Andi”. The problem was, Andi Sullivan is still working on who that player is. Not just what her body can do, and what she can build it to do, but how that would manifest on the pitch, and within the context of the team and its needs.

Two playoff games later, the essence of a vintage Andi Sullivan permeated both performances, but a spark of something new was present as well. As she prepares to play in a championship game for the first time with Michele Kang as the club’s owner, having missed the previous two through injury, Andi Sullivan is finally becoming the player she wants to be.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x